Adjunct Faculty Performance Evaluation
National Louis University is developing a consistent, University-wide adjunct faculty performance evaluation system. The goal is to provide clear expectations, meaningful feedback, and appropriate instructional support while enabling colleges and the Provost Office to monitor instructional quality. This work advances NLU’s Pillar 4 priority to establish a consistent adjunct faculty evaluation system.
This page outlines the draft policy, background, and process, while also inviting feedback.
Draft Policy
The draft Adjunct Faculty Performance Evaluation Policy establishes a consistent, university-wide approach to monitoring adjunct faculty performance, providing meaningful feedback, and supporting instructional improvement. Grounded in NLU's Teaching Excellence Framework and CARES values, the policy outlines performance expectations, evaluation indicators, review procedures, and proposed responsibilities for administering the system. The policy remains under development, and the Provost Office is seeking feedback. Download and review the draft policy and share your feedback to help inform its final development.
Draft Adjunct Faculty Performance Evaluation Policy
Policy development and next steps
The Adjunct Faculty Performance Evaluation Policy is still being developed. The Provost Office is currently inviting feedback from the Adjunct Council and the Faculty Development Committee. After that feedback is received and incorporated into a revised draft, Academic Cabinet will review the policy. The policy and supporting procedures will be finalized following this review process; implementation details and timing have not yet been established.
Why are we doing this?
Adjunct faculty bring vital expertise to our classrooms and are essential to NLU’s mission. To support their ongoing development as an educator, our shared evaluation system establishes transparent expectations alongside structured opportunities for feedback and instructional growth. By standardizing continuous feedback across all colleges, programs, and modalities, this system expands NLU’s effective teaching practices to ensure every instructor has the resources and guidance needed to succeed.
What is the proposed approach?
All newly hired adjunct faculty will participate in required new faculty onboarding and will be included in routine term-by-term performance monitoring. Additional evaluation can be initiated by faculty as a growth opportunity or when performance indicators, student complaints, administrative issues, or other documented concerns warrant review. Routine monitoring is not a formal evaluation.
How will the process work?
- Monitor: Review relevant performance information each term.
- Identify: Flag possible concerns and successes from dashboard indicators or other documented sources.
- Review in context: Consider the evidence, course circumstances, and other relevant factors.
- Consult: Discuss concerns with the faculty member when further evaluation is warranted.
- Support: Offer appropriate observation, coaching, professional development, or an improvement plan.
- Follow up: Document actions and determine whether concerns are resolved.
What information may be considered?
Possible indicators include end-of-course evaluation scores, comments and response rates; DFW (drop, fail, withdraw) rates; course readiness; engagement and responsiveness in D2L; timely grade submission; teaching observations; and teaching assignment history. Specific measures and thresholds are still being developed. No single indicator automatically establishes unsatisfactory performance.
Our shared performance expectations
The Teaching Excellence Framework describes effective instruction through three dimensions: Subject Matter Guide; Designer & Teacher; and Community Builder. The CARES framework establishes professional expectations that are Collaborative, Accountable, Responsive, Empathetic, and Solution-Oriented. Together, these frameworks inform how performance evidence is interpreted and how improvement is supported.
Shared responsibility
The proposed model assigns university-wide standards and oversight to the Provost Office; dashboard coordination and development resources to CTLE; implementation and personnel oversight to college leadership; direct faculty consultation and instructional follow-up to chairs and directors; and continuous learning and development to the adjunct faculty member. These assignments remain under discussion.
Frequently Asked Questions
No. All adjunct faculty participate in routine term-by-term monitoring as an ongoing touchpoint to ensure alignment with institutional standards. A more comprehensive evaluation occurs when a faculty member requests feedback for professional growth, or when specific indicators or documented concerns warrant closer review. As part of initial onboarding and support, some colleges or programs may also include a formative teaching observation for newly hired adjuncts.
Reviews can be initiated either proactively by faculty or in response to institutional indicators. Faculty may request a targeted review at any time to receive coaching or feedback on specific teaching goals. Reviews may also be prompted by dashboard indicators, teaching observations, academic supervision, student feedback, or missed administrative expectations. An initial flag or inquiry simply triggers a preliminary, supportive look—never an automatic negative finding.
No. Student evaluations are just one lens into the classroom experience and are always interpreted in context—alongside response rates, qualitative comments, course dynamics, other teaching evidence, and professional judgment—to help identify areas where coaching or resources might be helpful.
DFW rates help identify broader course or student-support patterns worth examining collaboratively. They are never used as stand-alone measures of teaching quality and are always evaluated alongside course context and student demographics.
An initial review determines how best to proceed. Depending on the context, the inquiry may be closed with no further action, addressed through a collaborative conversation with the faculty member, or followed by a tailored support plan and additional evaluation to help strengthen teaching practices.
The system is designed to connect faculty with practical, constructive resources tailored to their goals. Depending on your needs, support may include formative teaching observations and feedback, one-on-one instructional coaching, co-teaching opportunities, strategies for student engagement, course organization assistance, and workshops through the Center for Teaching and Learning Excellence (CTLE).
All new adjunct faculty complete the New Faculty Onboarding Program, which is designed to set instructors up for success from day one. While onboarding is separate from the ongoing evaluation process, both share the goal of supporting teaching excellence. CTLE, colleges, and HR collaborate on onboarding, with specific details published separately.
No. The evaluation framework takes a holistic view of teaching. In addition to dashboard metrics, faculty-initiated growth goals, formative teaching observations, supervisory check-ins, student feedback, and administrative touchpoints all inform the process.
To protect faculty privacy and foster open, developmental conversations, access to evaluation records is strictly limited to authorized university personnel. Clear guidelines for documentation, access permissions, and retention will be established through formal university procedures.
No. This framework is currently a working draft, and the Provost Office is actively gathering input from the Adjunct Council and the Faculty Development Committee. That faculty feedback will directly inform revisions before the policy goes to the Academic Cabinet for review. Specific metrics, thresholds, and implementation timelines are still being refined.
Just as the system supports continuous improvement for faculty, the University will continuously refine the evaluation process itself. The Provost Office will partner regularly with the Adjunct Council, Faculty Senate (via the Faculty Development Committee), Academic Cabinet, and individual colleges to assess how the system is working and identify opportunities to better support adjunct educators.
